During a round of Wild Cards Going Both Ways, the topic of five-of-a-kind was raised. The generally accepted rule states that any five-of-a-kind beats any straight flush (including a royal flush). But does that make sense?
In a five-card stud game, where there is just a single completely wild joker, the chances of hitting five of a kind are 1 in 220,745. In that same game, the chances of hitting a straight flush (including a royal) are 1 in 14,067. In this case the five-of-a-kind is much harder to make, so the generally accepted rule makes sense.
However, when you add more cards (and more wild cards), the odds change. Depending on the rules of the game, it might be much easier to make a five-of-a-kind than a straight flush. So should the rules change?
Probably not. You’d have to recalculate the odds for each and every new rule you introduce to the game.
And think about this: A 7-high flush is MUCH harder to make than an ace-high flush. And yet everyone agrees that an ace-high flush beats a 7-high flush.
Jackpot is now $73.00.